Wouldn't it be easier for me to buy a much bigger size Cleatskins so I wouldn't have to stretch them to get them on my cleats?

Cleatskins work so well because they are very snug and secure. We would not recommend wearing Cleatskins which were anything less than snug.

Cleatskins acts as cleat covers for soccer, football, baseball, lacrosse, track, wrestling, golf and any cleated sport.  Cleatskins covers your cleats to protect your investment and save you time.  You rely on your cleats for performance.  Count on Cleatskins to keep them covered and protected.

Designed for athletes of any age, Cleatskins are available for soccer, baseball, football, rugby, softball, field hockey, lacrosse, cycling, track and field and other cleated shoes in a variety of colors and sizes.  Other sport shoes, such as those used for wrestling and basketball, also benefit from Cleatskins.